We appreciate each and every one of you for taking the time to read Market Minds. Buckle up and enjoy the free value, and you won’t want to miss… a nine-level Michigan home that seems to have a different outfit for every season.
New and Resale Homes Cost About the Same per Square Foot, but Builder Buyers Pay Lower Rates
Price: a gap that size erases
New homes list at a higher median price than existing homes, but they are also larger. Adjusted for size, the two are almost even: $218 per square foot for new homes in the third quarter and $219 for resales.
That national match reflects where builders work. New construction is concentrated in the South and in suburbs where land costs less. So the figures say nothing about whether a new home sells for the same as a comparable older one nearby.
The two segments have also moved differently. New home listing prices have held roughly flat for three years. Existing home prices slipped 1.5% from a year earlier, as resale sellers were slower to let go of expectations set in 2021 and 2022.
Financing: where the gap opens
Reduced rates are builders' most common buyer incentive this year. Some come from lenders that offer below-market rates in exchange for the volume of buyers a builder sends them. In other cases, builders pay for the lower rate directly, either as a temporary buydown or for the life of the loan.
The result shows up in what buyers pay. In the third quarter, the average starting rate for new home buyers was 5.01%, against 6.15% for existing home buyers. On a $400,000 purchase with 10% down, that works out to about $258 a month less in interest in the first year.
How long the savings last
Many buydowns are temporary. A common 3/2/1 structure cuts the rate by three points in year one, two in year two and one in year three, then returns to the market rate.
A gap remains on permanent loans. Comparing only 30-year fixed mortgages, new home buyers pay about $117 a month less in interest, and that lasts all 360 months. For builders, the incentives help sell more homes at higher prices, which may explain some of why new home listing prices have held steady while resale prices slipped.
The Takeaway: Because builders have leaned on financing incentives while keeping median list prices steady, new and resale homes can look evenly priced per square foot while their buyers carry different monthly costs. How long that difference lasts depends on whether the lower rate is a temporary buydown or fixed.
In most states, a clean license lookup doesn't mean a clean record
What the lookup is supposed to show
State real estate commissions tell buyers and sellers to look up an agent's license before hiring. A clean result reads as a clean history. Anyone checking a referral partner, a new hire or the agent across the table would read it the same way.
A Consumer Policy Center review tested that reading. Fellow Wendy Gilch searched each state's free lookup for agents with known disciplinary records or recent criminal charges. Of 47 states that could be rated, two earned a "good" rating.
Where the record goes missing
In 16 states, the lookup showed no sign of the action, no document and no work history. Only three states flagged discipline in the first result for an agent. Elsewhere it took clicks, scrolling or a downloaded PDF.
Some states publish actions in newsletters or batched pages without linking them to the licensee's record, so the lookup appears clean. Others showed no action for agents the state had disciplined. One placed a green check mark next to "disciplinary action."
Some violations never reach the record. Commissions can close cases with private letters. In Oregon, educational letters for minor violations far outnumbered public actions in 2025, and recipients aren't named. Many states also wait for a conviction or guilty plea before acting on felony charges, leaving charged agents licensed with clean records for months or years.
Where the system works
Illinois flags actions on the licensee summary and explains them in plain language. Arizona explains actions and lists past brokerages, though they sit deeper in the profile. Only Arizona and California show work history.
Even in those states, the records sit inside lookup tools that web searches can't open. When Gilch ran the same agents through the chatbot Claude, it found nothing in 34 of 47 states, Illinois and Arizona included. What it did find came from meeting minutes, PDF orders and newsletters.
"The information was public, just not where commissions tell consumers to look," Gilch wrote. Agents near state borders often hold several licenses, and no public national database ties those records together.
The Takeaway: Much discipline is published somewhere, in minutes, newsletters and orders the official lookup doesn't connect. Private letters and pending felony charges never reach the license record at all, so a blank result can hide both kinds.
Brief sponsor break
Invest Alongside a $12B Real Estate Owner/Operator

Choose individual real estate investments alongside Lightstone. 20%+ GP co-investment in every offering, the same assets we pursue with our own capital. Our scale, your advantage. $100K minimum investment. For accredited investors.
Any message that includes model/proforma/targeted figures need a disclosure at the end such as: "This communication is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. Any such offer or solicitation will be made exclusively through the definitive offering documents. All investments involve risk of loss, including the potential loss of principal. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Any targeted returns or projections are forward-looking statements, are based on current assumptions, and are not guarantees of future performance. Actual results may differ materially.
Expired and withdrawn listings show where buyers stopped saying yes
Failed listings mark the ceiling
Sold comps show the prices buyers accepted. Expired, canceled and withdrawn listings in the MLS show the prices they turned down. As the market shifts toward buyers and pricing has to be more precise, that second set fills in what solds leave out.
Say recent comparable sales run from $600,000 to $625,000. A wider search turns up a similar home that listed at $675,000, cut its price twice and expired. Another sat at $650,000 for months before the seller withdrew it. Other sellers have already tested the top of the range, and they paid the carrying costs.
Three steps to add to a CMA
Pull the failures: Search expired, canceled and withdrawn listings alongside sold, active and pending properties.
Reconstruct the journey: Check the original price, each reduction, days on market, any relisting and the eventual outcome. A house that sold after being canceled and relisted carries a record of every price buyers passed on first.
Find what beat them: Look at what sold while those listings sat. If buyers bought the renovated house or the one on the better lot, the market was working, and buyers chose other homes.
Check why a listing failed
Price is one reason a listing fails among several. Sellers change their minds, job transfers fall through, repairs surface and agents get fired. Some sellers get an acceptable offer and decide not to move.
A call to the previous listing agent about showing activity and why the seller stopped can sort this out. Twenty-seven showings with no offers means buyers came and passed. Two showings in four months means something different.
What the long route costs
Compare a house that started high, cut, expired and relisted with similar homes priced near where buyers were buying. The comparison shows whether the high starter sold for less, plus the extra months of mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, utilities and upkeep. After long exposure and repeated cuts, buyers can start asking what's wrong with a house.
For a seller who says "we can always come down," that comparison puts a local price on coming down.
The Takeaway: Failed listings sharpen a price only when the reason they failed is known. Read next to what sold in the same months, they show which prices buyers in that market have already turned down.
🧰 IN THE TOOLBOX
Tools and resources built to help real estate professionals work smarter. Explore what could make a difference in your business.
ManyChat automates replies to Instagram and Facebook comments and direct messages. It can help agents respond to inquiries, collect contact information and move potential clients toward follow-up.
🏡 Visualize property improvements with AI
HomeDesigns.ai uses AI to generate interior and exterior design concepts from property photos. Agents can explore renovation possibilities, show alternative styles and help buyers visualize a property's potential.
🏘️ Research rental properties and market data
RentCast provides rental estimates, comparable properties and local market data. Useful for agents, property managers and investors evaluating rental opportunities or comparing rental prices in a specific market.
Use code BIGDEAL for 20% off.
Some links may be affiliate links, which means Market Minds may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
WORTH A READ
👀 This week, we’re making room for one more newsletter in your inbox — one we think is worth a look.

REI.School is your insider guide to building wealth through real estate. Whether you’re just getting started or growing your portfolio, we’ve got you covered. Join us as we take a deep dive into real estate investing, where we break down the strategies you need to learn, build, and succeed with over 320 articles.
The House That Changes With the Seasons
For $1.05 million, this Michigan home packs nine levels into just 1,650 square feet. Its translucent, reflective exterior shifts appearance with the surrounding landscape, from snowy winters to green summers.
There's a rooftop terrace overlooking Lake Michigan, three bedrooms and four bathrooms. The house may blend into the scenery, but the architecture certainly doesn't.
Check it out👇
TL;DR (Too Long; Didn’t Read)
New-home buyers are getting a financing advantage even as builders hold prices steady. New and existing homes list for nearly the same price per square foot, but buyers of new homes secured average starting mortgage rates of 5.01%, compared with 6.15% for resales. Some of those savings are temporary, making the type of incentive as important as the initial rate. Meanwhile, a review of state real estate licensing systems found that only two of 47 states earned a good rating for making disciplinary records accessible. In 16 states, official lookups failed to reveal known actions, raising concerns for anyone checking an agent's background. And for agents pricing listings, homes that failed to sell offer valuable evidence. Reviewing their price histories, checking what buyers purchased instead and investigating why the listings ended can reveal pricing limits that closed sales alone miss.
💬 How useful was today’s Market Minds?
Have a great weekend - we’ll see you next Saturday.
Cheers 🍻
-Market Minds Team
The content of Market Minds is provided for informational purposes only and reflects personal opinions based on sources believed to be reliable. It does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or professional advice. Each reader is solely responsible for their own decisions.





